The Question of Identity

It was published as my weekly column BAAGHI in Daily Times on April 24, 2011

A popular line of argument, available to the analysts on Pakistan, has been that most of Pakistan’s problems trace their lineage to its foundations. The very idea of Pakistan, it is said, carries the seeds of not only communalism but also of a forced homogeneity as opposed to the spirit of pluralism and democracy. The argument per se seems to be based on distorted facts and is challengeable on many counts. It, however, remains to be seen after 63 years of existence, what primary identity the people of Pakistan own and why.

Immediately after its birth in August 1947, a deliberate mystification of a ‘unified identity’ and absence of meticulous handling of the ‘software’ of the new-born nation served the purpose of integration among diverse coalescing units and multi-ethnic, multi-cultural entities that made up Pakistan. The Two Nation theory that served the separatist purpose before partition provided the integration factor. ‘Because we’re different from Hindus, we’re homogeneous among ourselves’ became the easy answer to the complex problems the founding fathers foresaw without comprehending their future implications.

The effect of this confusion on present day Pakistan manifests itself in many ways. Sometimes it is the illusion of grandeur based on a glorified past, at others it is a global ambition to conquer the world. It gives rise to incurable animosity of the ‘other’ (aghiyaar — as the current chief minister of Punjab puts it), which trickles down to the youth in the form of the worst identity crisis more than half a century after the country’s birth. As the British Council’s 2009 report, ‘Pakistan: The Next Generation’, says, more than half of the youngsters of Pakistan seek their primary identity in religion rather than territorial bonding.

The identity of a people as a collective binds itself with the Weltanschauung (a comprehensive view of the world) as of the external world and ethical outlook as of the internal blueprint of that ‘collective’. The purpose of having solid footings for a shared identity is humans’ quest for social order, which is managed globally as well as at nation-state level, through an unproblematic conception of ‘self’ by each identity and orderly interactions among sets of identities and sub-identities.

In most cases, this functional need for identity is satisfied by culture, which comes from centuries of human experience in all fields of life including religion. However, some cultures develop themselves in primarily religious fashion while subsuming all other alternatives of culture. In a 21st century globalised world, monolith cultures devoid of any potential of egalitarianism and pluralism would be anything but viable.

A culture would be ‘religious’ when its worldview is based on the assumption (or belief) of another world being superior to the present one. Such a culture would put emphasis on a transcendental divine world rather than the empirical one. The ‘mundaneness’ of the present world would put a religious culture in an unavoidable position to undermine everything associated with the empirical world and empirical knowledge. Modernity and modern knowledge get superseded by an emphasis on that ‘other world’, which is glorified and fancied in such a culture, thus barring any potential or willingness to progress, prosper, or even contribute to the world of knowledge and to a robust and all-encompassing culture based on diverse expressions of human experience.

This condescension and superciliousness towards the empirical world comes from the introduction of organised religion in a particular society, as a deciding factor. Even worse results come from the promotion of organised religion (especially one particular religion overriding all others) as a supreme concept to direct the entire business of the state and of cultural evolution. A perfect recipe for a nation’s disaster: this was precisely the course chosen for Pakistan in its early years.

Looking for the causes of the present chaos in Zia’s Islamic dictatorship or Bhutto’s perceived appeasement of religious forces would be counterproductive unless we recognise the root of all ills. This root resides in our conscious choice of the culture we want to identify with. The very idea that we had a privilege of ‘choosing’ the culture instead of inheriting it from the soil got us on the wrong path. We made the choice only to derail ourselves from the natural course of cultural evolution, and we are facing the music now.

Ejaz Haider, senior columnist, points towards another important dimension of the issue in his recent piece. Haider argues that the inability of the ‘liberals’ (he probably uses the term in the European centrist sense) to identify with (and support) the state has left the field open and free for a nationalism based on a myriad of factors but not the state. The key point here is the absence of a strong primary identity embedded in the territorial basis of a nation-state. When the British Council informs about most of our youth not ready to be identified as belonging to this nation-state but to the religion, it points precisely to the ‘global’ nature of the Weltanschauung people have here. It is the same worldview (to borrow the concept from Weber) that pushes the people to look for a much-needed ideological anchor in a world outside their territorial belonging. This quest for the ideological anchor gives way to adoption of cultural elements that might be completely alien to the soil or opposite to indigenous realities and experiences.

In this sense, a ‘national identity’ would be essentially distinct from the religious identity. National identity would base itself on the territorial existence and the concept of nation-state, not on a religion or even a loose moral consideration that negates the importance of empirical existence. In its intent, national identity would place the real, earthly world at the primary position, unlike a religious identity. Failure to make this distinction in building ‘culture’ and ideology would only create a confused nation that binds itself in a modern state system but negates its importance by being religious in substance. The national identity would require a state and a society to be secular (without undermining the importance of the real world), egalitarian (composed of different communities and groups in an un-stratified manner) and where the political authority must remain with the people (a democratic polity where people’s choices are supreme).

A deeper look at each of the above-mentioned components of the ‘national identity’ reveals how far we have moved from claiming a true national identity. Achieving a prime, strong national identity is what should be placed at the top of the national priorities list for Pakistan. It might actually address the roots of conflict and chaos if not be the panacea. It is important, in short, to be Pakistani before being a Hindu, Christian, Sikh or — yes — a Muslim. The texts beginning from a clichéd ‘all of us are Muslims’, need to be totally shunned in favour of a nation state-based identity, which would not only drag the society towards egalitarianism, but also would define our wider international behaviour.

It is important to be a nation rather than a loose mass of people in continuous search of identity, giving a migraine to itself
and to the world.


34 thoughts on “The Question of Identity

  1. garden rakes says:

    I intended to create you that very small observation to say thanks a lot the moment again considering the wonderful tricks you have contributed on this site. It is simply tremendously open-handed of you to offer without restraint all most people would’ve supplied as an e book to make some bucks on their own, chiefly since you might well have tried it in the event you wanted. Those solutions also served as the fantastic way to understand that other people have a similar interest much like my own to realize a great deal more in regard to this issue. Certainly there are several more enjoyable instances up front for people who read carefully your website.


  2. computer forensics jobs says:

    Yesterday found your website while browsing on aol for some information.Impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good info here. Bookmarked your site, so I am sure I will visit again soon.


  3. improve golf swing says:

    My coder is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on several websites for about a year and am concerned about switching to another platform. I have heard very good things about Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any kind of help would be greatly appreciated!


  4. opticians shetland islands says:

    The very root of your writing whilst sounding agreeable in the beginning, did not settle very well with me after some time. Someplace within the sentences you actually managed to make me a believer unfortunately only for a very short while. I nevertheless have a problem with your jumps in logic and one would do nicely to help fill in those gaps. In the event you can accomplish that, I would surely be fascinated.


  5. get more women says:

    I¡¯m delighted that I have noticed this weblog. Lastly something not a junk, which we undergo extremely frequently. The website is lovingly serviced and stored up to date. So it have to be, thank you for sharing this with us.


  6. easy cooking says:

    Today found your blog while browsing on aol for some information.Impressed by your blog. Its both informative and interesting. The advice should help many of your visitors. Thanks.


  7. Antony Lockman says:

    I recently came across your article and have been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end. I would like to read newer posts and to share my thoughts with you.


  8. led grow light reviews says:

    The different types of these lamps include High Pressure Sodium (HPS) Lamps, , LED Grow Lights and Metal Halide Lamps. While alot or all of them have been picked at one point and are continuoly utilizedin this point of time to some level, LED Grow Lights are the preferred lamps since the day they were invented.


  9. prepaid phone cards says:

    Recently found your blog while browsing on yahoo for some information.I love what you have done here. You seem to have developed quite a community here. Shows what a bit of useful info without the frills is what most people are looking for.


  10. car york york says:

    Recently found your blog while browsing on google for some information.Been poking around your blog for a few months. Loved this article and the entire site! Am looking forward to reading more!


  11. bar stools and table says:

    Yesterday found your blog while browsing on google for some information.Thanks for the nice blog. It’s been very useful for me. Keep sharing ideas like this and we’ll all profit from them. Glad I found your blog! Thanks for sharing the info with us.


  12. xrumer seo service says:

    Top xrumer seo services – seize Leading serps and significant targeted visitors using our effective oneway links deals. Most profitable & thrifty link building service ever! – search engine optimization – backlinks to your site – internet marketing – search engine optimization techniques – social media


  13. no win no fee claims says:

    Recently found your site while browsing on bing for some information.Thanks for the nice blog. It’s been very useful for me. Keep sharing ideas like this and we’ll all profit from them. Glad I found your blog! Thanks for sharing the info with us.


  14. Valeria says:

    I do agree with all the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re very convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are too short for beginners. Could you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.


  15. Biggleswade plumbers says:

    Hey There. I discovered your weblog using msn. This is an extremely neatly written article. I’ll make sure to bookmark it and return to read extra of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I will definitely comeback.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s