Big Ban Hypes Political Islam

This originally appeared as my weekly column BAAGHI in Daily Times on April 17, 2011

“Shame on France. Hijab is our identity” — read a placard held by a burqa-clad, seven years old girl. She was part of a protest rally against the ban on burqa that took affect in France on April 11, 2011 after around two years of legislative deliberations within French parliament.

France became the first European country to ban full-face veil from general public space on Monday last week only to risk worldwide protests by Muslims supported by the followers of other religions who believe in democratic principles of equality and freedom of expression. Like all unified history that is textualised to suit a particular power agenda, this one also ignores some important peripheral histories. An important peripheral history to this particular event is that all protesting or detesting the ‘big ban’ are not fanatic, misogynist, bigoted Muslims. The protests have a wider range of spectrum than one would like to imagine while living in monochrome Samuel Huntington world.

Those protesting against the ban can be distinguished into three categories. One: European Muslims who believe hijab, burqa and face veil are essential part of their faith. Two: Muslims living around the world for whom this big ban is a manifestation of Islamophobia and an incursion on Muslims’ right to express and follow their religious beliefs. These Muslims might or might not be observing purdah in their families, but take Muslim religious symbols as essential part of their identity. Three: those who do not believe in purdah or in burqa or veil, but consider it Muslims’ (or any religious community’s) right to choose their attire. This group constitutes not only Muslims, but most secular individuals and groups as well, belonging to other religious communities.

Dealing with this mix of anti-ban rainbow may seem a bit complex. It involves dealing with theist belief system, ages old stereotypes, basic human right to self-expression, feminist view of women’s status in societies, secularism and democratic plurality. Complex it may seem, it is essential to examine the issue with a lens that allows you to see through all these prisms while not barring the vision in favour of species’ subjugation — may it be women or a particular religious community.

First group, for example, seems to believe in one disputed version of scriptures allowing veil (or making it obligatory) upon women. Even a cursory view of works by a wide range of Islamic scholars makes it clear the veil is a highly disputed matter, the validity of which is yet to be proved through Quran or hadith. A feminist’s take would be to review the concept under ijtihad even if proven to be a part of holy scriptures. The proposition has due weight. Saner sections of Muslim scholarship might be urged to deal with the issue and resolve it once for all.

The second group, which insists on face veil or burqa, is the one that takes this subjugating covering as a symbol of their identity. In its intent, this concept seems highly divisive of a modern world’s society that has to be plural in its formation in order to give communities equal footings in one particular territorial unit. This propensity of religious communities’ insistence on ‘specificity’ and ‘otherisation’ not only disfigures pluralistic social order, but also becomes a contrivance for victimisation of their own selves. Muslims especially need to overhaul their system of ‘identity management’. The politics of identity must not be played at the expense of women’s emancipation. Face veil, howsoever it is taken — as cultural expression or identity — objectifies women in most perverse manner just as a bikini ad does, even worse. Muslims must, repeat must, get rid of such symbols of utter ignorance, stone-age patriarchy, fascism and misogyny. Women need to be celebrated, not feared to damage a society’s moral code if they appear in public space with their faces visible. Moreover, it is political Islam that is getting hyped up throughout the world using this ban and through veil.

The third group speaking against the ‘big ban’ comprises even progressive, secular and egalitarian people from multiple religious identities. Over last week, I tried to interact with diverse groups of people on different social networking sites and initiated the discussion using ‘shock and awe’. I displayed a weird picture as my display picture on Twitter, with an image of burqa clad woman showing half of her body completely nude. Followers from Pakistan (not all of them) were concerned about my morality in displaying such a picture and wondered whether I could wear such clothes myself.

Very interesting reaction came from Pakistani seculars/progressives and Indian right-wingers as well as centrists. While the right-wing Indians were cheering my pro-ban statements, Sonali Ranade, an Indian trader, was intrigued by it and said: “Love to see our ultra orthodox righteous cheering on @marvisirmed’s rebellion against purdah. Wud they support it for the women at home?” (sic). She further elaborated her point with a blunt statement: “Hope to see the same activism against our khap panchayat imposed ban on jeans & mobiles for girls!” (sic). Renowned South Asian journalist from NDTV, Barkha Dutt stated: “Huge problems with its enforcement. But I say no to Sarkozy’s enforced policing too.”

Pakistan’s promising youth and leading figure in anti-dictatorship protests during 2007 movement, Samad Khurram, was worried about those who observe veil as their personal choice. On my reminder of the social conditioning that might have resulted in observing a subjugative practice, Samad raised an important question: “A new form of conditioning in response to another conditioning is okay?” The discourse, here, missed the point that a voice of dissent against pervasive exploitation should not be diluted by the ‘conditioning’ label. It should rather enrich the debate with alternative point of view. Undeterred by the polemics, journalist Raza Rumi reminded: “Correction. Burqa has nothing to do with Islam. During Hajj, Divine injunction is not to cover their faces.” Rumi goes on to ask: “Would you also condemn the banning of suttee by the British in 19th century because it was freedom of choice?”

The secular viewpoint, to sum it up, revolves around the ‘right to choose attire’ which has been usurped in France by this big ban. Burqa or veil, I am afraid, is more than ‘attire’. It is misogynist coating on body and soul of women, the devastating effect of which could not be reduced to concepts like ‘freedom’ and ‘right’ to choose attire or to express. If it is about the right to suppress women, or women’s ‘right’ to choose subjugation, a progressive modern mind of whatever religious leaning should detest. Protesting a burqa ban must not take precedence over enforcement of purdah by the Saudi and Iran governments. The educated minds must choose their fights carefully.

Post Script: France might have become the first European country to put a public ban on veil, it must be remembered that it was Turkey to put a ban on headscarves for women in public sector jobs. The Turkish ban could not be lifted despite the fact that wives of both the president and the prime minister wear headscarves.


35 thoughts on “Big Ban Hypes Political Islam

  1. Raziq says:

    “Pakistan’s promising youth and leading figure in anti-dictatorship protests during 2007 movement, Samad Khurram,…” Apart from the topic, I think this sentence is highly objectionable. How acan an idiot can be termed as “Pakistan’s promising youth” who utilizes an American Scholarship for studying at an American Institute and then ignores all established manners, shows utter disgusting behaviour while receiving an award from the US Ambassador.

    Being liberal, you must not have jumped in this discussion and be on the other side. BecauseFrance has not banned this being the chosen right but as a symbol of faith. The people who use veil doint use it as a right of choice of attire but as a religious or faith obligation. Since all matters relating to faith fall in the personal domain of a person, so these must remain in personal domain and not in public. So the ban was necessary. We here in Pakistan cannot even think of about the fruits of the separation of religion from the state as we have not experienced this. Dont you think women roaming in bazars in black, blue and green veils offer a disgusting look. They in fact hurl insult on men and other women as they can look at others but conceal their identity. In my opinion Veils must be banned here too and work for separation of faith matters from the State must be carried out at the urgent. It is the only future course.


  2. annie says:

    thanks for these two posts. made me think a lot. i personally have huge issues with purdah or even head scarves but have always thought that perhaps other muslim women should have the freedom if they want it. but you made me think about the nature of that choice once again. so thank you. and this also reinforces my faith in public conversations and the necessity of expressing one’s views without fear of giving offence.


  3. buying seeds says:

    I wanted to create you a bit of remark to be able to say thanks a lot as before relating to the pleasing things you’ve featured on this page. It is simply shockingly generous of you to allow openly all that a lot of folks could have advertised for an electronic book to get some dough on their own, notably considering the fact that you could possibly have tried it if you ever decided. These ideas also acted like the fantastic way to be aware that someone else have the same eagerness similar to my own to grasp significantly more on the topic of this matter. I’m certain there are lots of more pleasant moments in the future for individuals who examine your website.


  4. golf swing trainers says:

    Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage? My website is in the exact same area of interest as yours and my users would truly benefit from a lot of the information you present here. Please let me know if this ok with you. Regards!


  5. opticians in aberdeenshire says:

    Together with almost everything which seems to be building within this area, your viewpoints are actually somewhat refreshing. Nonetheless, I appologize, but I can not subscribe to your entire theory, all be it stimulating none the less. It seems to me that your opinions are generally not completely validated and in reality you are generally your self not fully convinced of your point. In any event I did appreciate examining it.


  6. impress a girl says:

    Congratulations on possessing certainly one of probably the most subtle blogs Ive arrive throughout in a while! Its simply wonderful how a lot you’ll be capable of take into account away from a factor mainly simply due to how visually gorgeous it is. You’ve place collectively an incredible weblog web site area –nice graphics, movies, layout. This is definitely a should-see website!


  7. get women says:

    I’m still learning from you, but I’m improving myself. I certainly love studying the whole lot that is written in your blog.Preserve the tales coming. I beloved it!


  8. surrogacy says:

    Recently found your website while browsing on bing for some information.This is a very interesting post. Could do with more sites like yours. Great content and varied topic choices.


  9. easy cooking says:

    Today found your blog while browsing on aol for some information.Useful information shared with clarity. Thanks for the great tips and advice. Enjoyed particularly this post.


  10. led grow light says:

    The various kinds of these lights include , , LED Grow Lights and . While many or mostof them have been popular at one point and are still used today to some level, LED Grow Lighting are the preferred lamps since the point in time they were invented.


  11. LG Revolution Accessories says:

    I have been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this info So i am happy to convey that I’ve an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to don’t forget this web site and give it a look on a constant basis.


  12. car york york says:

    Recently found your blog while browsing on bing for some information.Thanks for the nice blog. It’s been very useful for me. Keep sharing ideas like this and we’ll all profit from them. Glad I found your blog! Thanks for sharing the info with us.


  13. bar stools says:

    Yesterday found your website while browsing on aol for some information.Thought this was a really good post, delighted I came across it. Will have to spend some time reading your other posts and comments.


  14. garmin golf gps says:

    Today found your blog while browsing on bing for some information.Impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good info here. Bookmarked your site, so I am sure I will visit again soon.


  15. Muchacho says:

    Hi there, a very good read and it sometimes just takes someone to post something like this to make me realise where I’ve been going wrong! Just added the site to my bookmarks so will check back now and then. Cheers.


  16. no win no fee claims says:

    Just Now found your blog while browsing on bing for some information.Thanks for the nice blog. It’s been very useful for me. Keep sharing ideas like this and we’ll all profit from them. Glad I found your blog! Thanks for sharing the info with us.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s