Heck, No HEC!

Published as weekly column BAAGHI in Daily Times on Sunday, April 10, 2011

Following the decision of the Parliamentary Commission on the Implementation of the Eighteenth Amendment (PCIEA), the federal cabinet approved the devolution of five ministries to the provinces, including the ministry of education. While news anchors started steaming on their pulpits about the ‘devolution of the HEC’, one was compelled to see the issue with objectivity, setting all politics aside for a moment.

The hoopla has been constructed such that one tends to confuse higher education with the existence of the HEC. A reality check might help in removing this muddle. The HEC was born out of the sperm of a dictatorial regime and the womb of a fund-starved body, the University Grants Commission (UGC), working since 1974. Like all dictators in Pakistan, the last one too was obsessed with a centralised polity — a strong centre with little autonomy to the provinces. This has now been transformed into our collective psyche to undermine coalescing units as is evident from arguments currently given against the HEC’s devolution.

The popular arguments against the HEC’s devolution range from a concern for higher education in Pakistan, freezing of foreign aid for higher education in the absence of the HEC, halting ongoing scholarships, lack of coordination among and check on universities, etc. One has to admit the successful propaganda machine against the devolution by HEC beneficiaries and planners.

The vice chancellors (VCs) of 133 universities, as claimed by media reports, resolved against the devolution. Look a little closer and you will see and find that only 40 VCs (beneficiaries of the system) present in that particular meeting, out of 133 universities, had actually “expressed concerns over the devolution”. Even these 40 did not agree with protesting on the streets against it.

The HEC authorities used the rumour factory to propagate confusion about the issue. Rumours about the freezing of foreign aid for studying abroad were unleashed in the media, which was readily refuted by the biggest HEC donor, USAID, that made clear that their $ 250 million support still stands. The most vicious step that the HEC arbitrarily took was halting ongoing scholarships, just to spread panic and confusion among the students. Sadly, it worked. Without even slight understanding of the issue or any inclination to probe the facts, general opinion tilted in the direction the vested interest group wanted it.

The Federation of All Pakistan Universities Academic Staff Associations (FAPUASA), one of the primary and key stakeholders, however, is still silent on the issue. In fact, many members of FAPUASA in informal discussions have revealed how apt this decision would prove in steering higher education in Pakistan. A professor of economics from Government College University explained how the HEC had been promoting bureaucratic and fascist tendencies by being highly centralised and having a dictatorial authority. Many a time, the academic staff of different universities was seen complaining about the unfair and unjust practices of the HEC that undermined equal opportunities for all.

Not long ago, academic staff in Sindh and Balochistan staged demonstrations against the HEC for being extremely partial against PhD professors and students from smaller provinces. The partiality of the HEC went to the level where PhD holders in Pashto, Sindhi and Balochi were denied the same allowances as for other disciplines. One can see the same arrogance and contempt towards the smaller provinces in the devolution debate undermining the provinces’ capability to deal with higher education. Had the HEC not been that self-serving and centralised, it would have built at least some capacity among the provinces over the last eight years.

Some political parties made a bewildering U-turn by quickly jumping onto the populist position. The PCIEA does not mention any strong voice of dissent, refuting all claims of a Punjab-based political party currently insisting on the status quo. It is interesting to note that Punjab is probably the only province that had anticipated the devolution earlier than any other province, and had made its own body on higher education, which has now been working for quite some time and leaves one wondering why the HEC or Punjab government could not strengthen it for performing the HEC’s functions at the Punjab level.

Leaving aside politics and coming back to academics, an objective look at the performance of the HEC might give us some clue towards a solution or at least direction. The white elephant, as the HEC is called by leading academicians, has been notorious for softening the system for quantity while compromising the quality of the scholars on the one hand, and disrupting teaching practices in universities on the other. Instead of carrying out their primary responsibilities, i.e. teaching, the academic staff of the universities was funnelled into pursuing peripheral activities like the publication of their papers in international journals that would win them promotions and other incentives. No wonder most supervisors would sign your PhD thesis without even reading it because they have to work on more important things — their own publications.

This emphasis on published papers did not distract only the teachers from their primary responsibility, but also aspiring PhD students. The unfair condition of GRE qualification at the time of degree awarding (not at the time of PhD admission) aside, Pakistan is probably the only country where the condition of at least three publications is imposed for awarding a PhD. You better concentrate on publications instead of your own thesis, says the HEC to PhD students.

Moreover, most senior, accomplished and foreign qualified professors were not certified as PhD supervisors, for not being among ‘favourites’ or for not pleading before the HEC for it. Many renowned names like Professor Hasan-Askari Rizvi, Professor Ijaz Shafi Gilani, Professor M Islam and many others come into this category. The HEC’s obsession with increasing the number of PhD scholars while compromising their quality made the HEC suffer itself, which was seen when it announced the selection criteria for the selection of VCs against recent vacancies that asked for a foreign PhD degree, not one from the HEC.

The assertions that foreign universities would stop recognising Pakistani degrees in the absence of the HEC remain as far from reality as the HEC authorities are from egalitarianism. One wonders if Pakistan did not produce any degree holder and if the world never recognised any Pakistani degree before the HEC or, for that matter, before the UGC. This insistence on being and remaining the only centralised dictatorial body to impose self-serving terms based mostly on whims and caprices of individuals in the HEC has not taken higher education very far — yet devolution is thought incapable of doing any better. Let us learn to respect the provinces and empower them. Let us ask the HEC authorities to go into their respective provinces and steer the devolution process ahead.

All said, it remains a necessity to build an authentic body for not only coordination, but also the rating of universities. More than universities, the departments need to be rated based on their academic records and excellence. Teachers need to be encouraged for applying the best possible teaching practices rather than pursuing selfish objectives of promotions and seeking ‘tenure track’ at the expense of academic activity. Academics need to sit down with the PCIEA and inter-provincial coordination ministry so as to facilitate and advise the process of devising an effective mechanism to replace a hegemonic HEC. VCs need to stop being politicians and the media needs to sit back, think, learn and then reflect on the subject leaving aside politics and giving way to the kind of objectivity that respects academics.

 

Advertisements

48 thoughts on “Heck, No HEC!

  1. Riz says:

    Oh My Lord!!! Curse on the liars and on those who with an evil intention try to malign sonme one/Some thing for no solid reason and with no proof. What ever has been stated in the Article in Baghi(rebellious) manifests the ignorance of the writer abt the facts and figures abt waht has been examplified in the article..It has become hard for me now to get as to why even the certain educated portion of our society has become the tool for certain Hypocrite,selfish and education enemiy politicians who have never wished and tried for the propagation of the Education in the country in fear of losing thier years of dominance….. For Lord’s sake let education flourish and prevail in the country.And ,in this regard let the well well and smooth functioning HEC do its work.Its the era of Knowledge Based Economy my dear!and any country lagging behind in this,would even find it difficult to retain its freedom…….. Let ask provincial governments to pay heed for the deplorable condition of the Schools and colleges being run under thier control,let us Question them as to what have they done so far in uplifting the education under their domain????

    Like

  2. Baaghi says:

    Would have been much better if you could specify some “lies” in the above piece, along with your corrections of the same. Would you sire? Many thanks in advance.

    Like

  3. Riz says:

    My Pleasure in Bringing the Factual Position before the public..
    Well,in Article ,the establishment of HEC has been misrepresented with an evil intention of creating hatred among people for HEC that
    1. it was not a federal entity and was forcibly made the said one BY A DICTATOR in order to usurp the rights of the Provinces making their autonomy limited,,

    So LET ME FIRST OF ALL MAKE IT VERY CLEAR that HEC was establishd due to being the need of the hour in order to expedite and enhance the research work in the UNIVERSITIES + Degree Awarding Institutes(DAIs) so that Pakistan could compete with the world in the field of Science and Techonology and to improve the Quality of the work and the Standard of the education in universities because it is an established fact now that the economies of most of the countries of the world are have become and are becoming knowledge based……and the Role of UGC is before every one ….. Being controlled by the bureaucary and the goverments in power, it never voiced against its samall funding,but on the Contraray the HEC esatblishing Governmet and the HIGHLY educated people in HEC who new the importance of the Higher Education in the country’s development on strong footings in the years to come, agreed to increase its budget for Research work and uplift of the universities and DAIs across the country across the board….

    Like

  4. Riz says:

    My Pleasure in Bringing the Factual Position before the public..
    Well,in Article ,the establishment of HEC has been misrepresented with an evil intention of creating hatred among people for HEC that
    1. it was not a federal entity and was forcibly made the said one BY A DICTATOR in order to usurp the rights of the Provinces making their autonomy limited,,

    So LET ME FIRST OF ALL MAKE IT VERY CLEAR that HEC was establishd due to being the need of the hour in order to expedite and enhance the research work in the UNIVERSITIES + Degree Awarding Institutes(DAIs) so that Pakistan could compete with the world in the field of Science and Techonology and to improve the Quality of the work and the Standard of the education in universities because it is an established fact now that the economies of most of the countries of the world are have become and are becoming knowledge based……and the Role of UGC is before every one ….. Being controlled by the bureaucary and the goverments in power, it never voiced against its samall funding,but on the Contraray the HEC esatblishing Governmet and the HIGHLY educated people in HEC who knew the importance of the Higher Education in the country’s development on strong footings in the years to come, agreed to increase its budget for Research work and uplift of the universities and DAIs across the country across the board….

    Like

  5. Riz says:

    2. The real and fact based calculated DESTRUCTIVE STATE OF Higher education in the country in case of desolving /Devolving HEC has very sadly been termed as a propaganda.Very sad indeed and to me the igonocence (ignorance+innocence)displyed in the Article aroused pity for the writer.

    Let me inform you that it was the result of the untiring efforts and the Worldwide established CREDIBILITY of HEC for honoring the merit and for sincerely
    promoting higher education in the country that many developed countries like US,UK,Germany,France,China,etc contibuted generously in the cause..BUT SINCE almost every country in the world is well aware of the credibility of institutions of the country( except Judiciary and HEC) and of Politicians and the bureaurates that they ,from time to time voiced their concerns regarding their corruption and the irregularities,now with their this decision of desolving /devolving HEC,the Donor Agencies are reluctant to issue the committed funds for higher Education in the country and these concerns were communicated to the Chairman HEC by USAID,and WB officials that it would be difficlut for these agencies to interact seperately with the provinces in case HEC is Desolved/Devolved.and there is no solid or written assurance that they will not with hold the said funding/Loan(s)
    and it’s mandatory to mention that the Scholrs get Stipend on monthly basis and not in lump sum,so the disturbance in the payment of their Stipend is result of the disturbance of the release of funds to HEC by the finance..
    And its altogether evil of the writer’s to call this factual position as propaganda by some beneficiries/Planners..
    I want to know as to who are the said beneficiaries/Planners???

    Like

  6. Riz says:

    3. Well,except a few selfish and hypocrite persons majority of the people whether VCs of the Universities,members of the civil Society,Politicians,Students,Scholars are against the proposed Dissolution/Devolution of HEC and that is apparent from the protests all over the country..
    In addition to this.. Those who talk against the Strict policies of HEC are only those who were accustomed of Plagiarism and getting PHds like that BUT HEC stopped their way by Introducing Certain Software that detects even a single line in the thesis of any Scholar if it has been Stolen… So how would such Steps be welcomed by those Plagiarists…….

    Like

  7. Riz says:

    It’s Amazing of the Writers’ call for establishment of an other Body for Higher Education regulating despite the fact of the existance of a well well established,Credible,Well organized,Transparent HEC in the country… Really. nw iam bursting into laghters at the intentional IGNOCENCE of the writer.. What should i say after encountering Such recommendations by the writer……!!!!!!!!!.??????Let me controle my laughter…….. Thanks……

    Like

  8. Waqas ur Rahman says:

    Madam

    Would you please tell me how well the institutions are being run currently under provinces?
    They cant run a school properly, forget about Higher Education.

    and if the quality of PHD’s has gone down, then it means there is something wrong with Foreign universities because majority of them are qualified from Foreign University.

    We wont allow Fake Degree holders to decide our Future.

    Like

  9. Advertising agency Chertsey says:

    I’m impressed, I must say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is outstanding; the issue is something that not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.*Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

    Like

  10. kortingscode says:

    Have seen and heard about such an insect for the first time. I really like knowing about various types of insects and animals. The life cycle of the insect shared in here seems to be very interesting. Will look forward to more such interesting posts.

    Like

  11. climbers for shade says:

    Thank you a lot for giving everyone such a terrific possiblity to read articles and blog posts from this website. It really is so fantastic and also stuffed with a good time for me and my office friends to visit your website at the least three times weekly to learn the newest things you have got. Not to mention, I’m also always satisfied with the striking hints you serve. Selected 3 ideas in this posting are really the most efficient we have all ever had.

    Like

  12. improve golf swing says:

    We absolutely love your blog and find many of your post’s to be exactly I’m looking for. Would you offer guest writers to write content in your case? I wouldn’t mind writing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write related to here. Again, awesome web site!

    Like

  13. hosting says:

    Thank you for making the honest effort to discuss this. I think very strong approximately it and would like to read more. If it’s OK, as you achieve extra intensive wisdom, might you mind adding extra articles similar to this one with additional information? It would be extremely helpful and useful for me and my friends.

    Like

  14. Creative agencies London says:

    Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get something done.

    Like

  15. opticians midlothian says:

    The heart of your writing while sounding reasonable in the beginning, did not really settle well with me after some time. Somewhere throughout the paragraphs you actually were able to make me a believer but only for a while. I still have got a problem with your leaps in logic and one would do nicely to fill in those breaks. When you can accomplish that, I will surely be impressed.

    Like

  16. pick up artist says:

    Thanks for taking the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love learning extra on this topic. If doable, as you gain expertise, would you thoughts updating your weblog with additional info? This can be very helpful for me.

    Like

  17. surrogate parenting says:

    Today found your website while browsing on aol for some information.Love the website. Have you thought about RSS Feeds as a traffic source for your blog. They work for me, and bring me a nice bit of traffic.

    Like

  18. Rosalinda Armstong says:

    I recently came across your article and have been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end. I would like to read newer posts and to share my thoughts with you.

    Like

  19. prepaid phone cards says:

    Yesterday found your site while browsing on bing for some information.Impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good info here. Bookmarked your site, so I am sure I will visit again soon.

    Like

  20. led grow lamps says:

    The different kinds of these lights include , Incandescent Grow Lights, LED Grow Lights and . While alot or all of them have been picked at one timeframe and are continuoly used in this point of time to some level, LED Grow Lighting are the chosen light sources begining since the day they were introduced.

    Like

  21. best market solar says:

    Assets just like the one you mentioned here will likely be very helpful to me! Ill submit a hyperlink to this page on my blog. I am sure my guests will discover that very useful. Massive thanks for the helpful info i found on Area News Anyway, in my language, there will not be a lot good source like this.

    Like

  22. car york york says:

    Just Now found your website while browsing on aol for some information.This is a very interesting post. Could do with more sites like yours. Great content and varied topic choices.

    Like

  23. bar stools says:

    Today found your website while browsing on bing for some information.Impressed by your blog. Its both informative and interesting. The advice should help many of your visitors. Thanks.

    Like

  24. garmin approachg 5x says:

    Just Now found your website while browsing on aol for some information.Hey.. I’m not much into reading, but ended up reading lots of articles on your blog. Very interesting posts and comments, and very useful.

    Like

  25. Lose 10 Pounds says:

    I wanted to visit and allow you to know how much I treasured discovering your web blog today. I’d personally consider it a great honor to work at my office and be able to make real use of the tips shared on your web site and also be involved in visitors’ opinions like this. Should a position associated with guest author become offered at your end, you should let me know.

    Like

  26. xrumer linkbuilding says:

    Most effective xrumer seo services – seize Best serps together with significant traffic using our highly effective back-links deals. Most potent & affordable backlink building service ever! XrumerGod.com – search engine ranking optimization – quality backlinks – on the internet marketing – search engine marketing – social bookmarking

    Like

  27. weight loss says:

    You can definitely see your expertise in the paintings you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. Always go after your heart.

    Like

  28. Rudolf Pigford says:

    Thanks for taking your time to discuss this with us, I feel greatly about it and love to study more on this topic. If it is possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is vastly helpful for me.

    Like

  29. Classie Scholtens says:

    It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s